The book / Guides / Do Most Worries Come True? What One Study Found

Do Worries Come True? What One Study Found

Short answer: do worries come true? In one small study, most didn’t. Twenty-nine university students wrote their worries down for ten days, then checked later, and about 91 per cent of what they worried about never happened. That’s one group over ten days, not a rule for everyone. The useful part is the habit of writing a worry down and checking it.

It’s late on a Sunday and an email lands from your landlord: “Could you give me a ring tomorrow when you get a minute?” That’s all it says. By midnight you’ve covered every possibility. The rent’s going up. They’re selling. You’ll have to find somewhere by the end of the month, and you’ve already priced the removal van in your head.

On Monday you ring. The boiler engineer needs to get in on Thursday, and could you be home to let him in?

You may have a night like that somewhere in your own memory. So it’s a fair question: how often does the thing we worry about actually happen?

What did the study actually find?

Lucas LaFreniere and Michelle Newman at Penn State ran the study, and it appeared in Behavior Therapy in 2020.

The 29 people taking part were university students, and all of them met the criteria for generalised anxiety disorder, which meant that for them worry was a constant rather than an occasional guest. For ten days each kept a paper journal. A text prompt on their phone four times a day reminded them to note down what they were worrying about, and they were free to add extra entries too.

Each night they reviewed every worry written so far, and they looked again twenty days after the last day of writing, marking whether each feared outcome had actually happened.

Roughly nine in ten of the worries, about 91 per cent, had not come true.

What percentage of worries never come true?

For those 29 students, over those ten days, about 91 per cent. That’s the honest answer, and it comes with limits worth keeping in view.

So I wouldn’t treat “91 per cent of worries” as a law. But it does fit a feeling many people will recognise: the version of tomorrow you build at night can be a good deal darker than the one that turns up.

So do worries come true, or does it just feel like they will?

It feels like they will, and there’s a reason for that.

Roy Baumeister, Ellen Bratslavsky, Catrin Finkenauer and Kathleen Vohs reviewed a broad sweep of research in 2001, in a long paper in the Review of General Psychology titled “Bad Is Stronger Than Good”. Whichever area they looked at, the bad had more pull on people than the good. A bad event shifted mood further than a good one, and a poor first impression formed more quickly and was harder to shift. Exceptions were very hard to find. Their suggested explanation was that across our species’ long past, noticing bad things closely helped people stay alive.

Also in 2001, Paul Rozin and Edward Royzman described a “negativity bias” in Personality and Social Psychology Review. A single bad part can ruin the whole more readily than a single good part can save it. Picture a lovely meal out where someone made one cutting remark. Which bit replays as you’re getting ready for bed?

So a mind that tilts towards the negative isn’t a bad habit you’ve picked up somewhere. Human minds commonly lean that way. A smoke alarm is a fair comparison. You want one that shrieks at a slice of burnt toast, because one that holds off until it’s certain the house is on fire is useless. Your mind’s alarm is set the same way.

Why can’t I stop worrying?

Because you’re asking an old survival system to stand down because you said so, and it doesn’t take orders like that. You can’t simply tell yourself to stop.

Worry also feels useful while you’re doing it. Sometimes it is: it gets people to check the lock and book the appointment. Plenty of worrying in the small hours, though, isn’t planning. It’s a handful of thoughts on a loop, round and round, never arriving anywhere. If it’s the nights that are hardest, the page on why worry won’t stop at night is for that.

You won’t stop worrying. Nobody does. What you can do is smaller: give the worry a sentence, and give it a date.

Two minutes: fear on one side, facts on the other

Try this now, two minutes. Choose one thing that keeps tugging at you this week.

  1. If a text or an email set it off, put your phone out of sight for now.
  2. Finish this sentence out loud or in your head: “The thing I’m scared of is…”
  3. Then finish a second one: “The facts I have are…” Leave out anything you’re guessing at.
  4. Jot the worry down as a single line in a notebook or on your phone, with today’s date beside it and a date one week on to look again.

On the check date, note what really happened. That’s what’s worth taking from the study: the checking, more than the figure. Kept in your head, a worry grows. Written on a page, it holds still long enough for you to have a proper look at it.

This is the book’s suggestion, not something the study tested. But it’s what those students had in front of them: a page, where each worry could be checked.

Questions people ask

Is the 91 per cent of worries figure real? Yes, it comes from a real study, LaFreniere and Newman, Behavior Therapy, 2020. It applies to 29 students over ten days, so it’s a finding about that group, not a promise about yours.

What about the worries that did come true? In that study, roughly one in ten did. Writing worries down isn’t about proving every fear wrong. It’s about seeing which ones need a plan and which ones can be left to sit.

Does a worry journal work? The study wasn’t designed to test that. What a worry journal does give you is a record, so you can see for yourself how your own forecasts turn out, instead of trusting the version that arrives at eleven at night.

Is it normal to worry this much? Spotting what might go wrong is part of what minds are made for, and they pick it up faster than they pick up what’s going well. Worrying doesn’t mean your mind is broken.

Where this comes from

This is Chapter 2 of You’re More Normal Than You Think, “Your Brain Is Built to Worry”. The back of the book has a Worry log with columns for the worry, the check date and what happened, and a sorting page for deciding which worries need a step and which can be left alone.

The first chapter is free to read at youremorenormal.com/read, and you can find the twelve feelings the book covers at youremorenormal.com/feelings.

Ahsan Raza

Related pages

  1. Why can’t I stop worrying at night?From chapter: Your Brain Is Built to Worry
  2. Why does my day look so grey?From chapter: Same Day, Different Lens
  3. How do I cope after a rejection or a setback?From chapter: When Things Go Wrong

More guides

  1. Why Is It Easier to Give Advice Than Take It?
  2. Why Do I Feel Better After Crying? Only Sometimes
  3. Healthy Striving vs Perfectionism: How to Tell
  4. How Common Is Imposter Syndrome, Really?
Get the book, $6.99Read the first chapter free
You can unsubscribe at any time.